If you caught the unboxing of my August Stitch Fix box, you’ll already know that I was pretty unimpressed with what my stylist sent me this time (haven’t watched the unboxing yet? Check it out below!). The last two boxes I received (check them out here) were full of hits, so the fact that this one was so much of a miss was a huge bummer.
As it was my 3rd fix, and I have been incredibly detailed about what I did and didn’t like about each of the pieces I’ve been previously sent, I definitely expected a great collection of pieces, but that’s not at all what I got.
What I requested: “I’m breastfeeding so tops / dresses that allow for easy nursing are great. I have an hourglass figure, love blues & stay away from pastels. I don’t want any jewelry / accessories. I would love boho styles and really really really want to try out a cute romper that would work on a long torso!”
19 Cooper brand Alannis Crochet Strap Top $58.
I was hoping that I would love this, but alas it’s not even close to love. It’s pretty, but the colors are too pastel for me, the fit is terrible, especially around the straps and armpits, and the length is not flattering in the least.
Verdict? Returned.
Collective Concepts brand Hesperia Split Neck Top $58
Not my style at all. Everythign but the colors with this one was super off – the fit is terrible once again. The fabric is super soft but it’s too boxy, puffy, and way too short on both my arms and torso. Nothing lays where it’s supposed to, so I just look like I’m trying to hide a baby bump, so no question – this one is going back.
Verdict? Returned.
Loveappella brand Carlita Maxi Dress $68
Yikes. The second I brought this out of the box, I knew it was going to be a hard sell. The dress’ coloring is super similar to the KUT FROM THE KLOTH Kelsie Braided Detail Belted Maxi Dress that I got in my first fix, so once again I’m surprised that it was included in my Fix at all. While the material is really soft the coloring is way too pink for me. The fit was spot on with this one, except for the fact that it left me feeling a little too exposed up top, but I just couldn’t get over the pattern and color.
Verdict? Return.
Loveappella brand Bernardo Crochet Back Cardigan $58.
I think my stylist was trying to bring in a boho vibe to this fix with this cardigan, but it just misses the mark completely. Its almost exactly like the RENEE C Huebert Space Dye Open Cardigan that I got in my last fix, so I’m really surprised this was included at all because I have the same complaints in regards to the fact that for a $60 cardigan, I expected a little more substance and a better choice of fabric, but it just felt cheap and was too thin. The fit was weird and the dolman half sleeves looked silly on me.
Verdict? Returned.
Mavi brand Ruxin Slim Boyfriend Jean $118.
These were the one piece in the entire Fix that I remotely considered keeping. The denim is incredibly soft and they feel like the perfectly worn in pair of jeans. The distress level is nice, and they look nice, but they are way too bleached out and light in most areas, so I don’t feel like the coloring is flattering to my shape at all. The length was great, both cuffed and uncuffed, but they were HUGE in the waist so even if I did like them, I would’ve had to exchange them for a smaller size.
Verdict? Return.
I was let down on more than just the styling miss of this box. It turns out it arrived three days before I scheduled my Fix, which may sound great, but I was out of town until the day before I had everything scheduled, so I missed out on three days of trying on and I feel like my stylist definitely needed the extra time to find me better pieces. The dress (and technically the cardigan and jeans) was the only breastfeeding friendly piece of clothing and 19 Cooper tank was pastel, which is exactly what I said I didn’t want.
Another complaint this time around? The pricing. No way is that tank top something that I would ever pay $30 for, let alone the $58 the price tag reflects, and same with the $60 sweater. I have seen almost exactly the same pieces at Marshalls, TJ Maxx, Nordstrom and Nordstrom Rack for much MUCH less, so this leaves me with a sour taste.
Because I’m sending everything back, that does mean that I’m going to be losing out on my $25 styling fee, but nothing was worth it this time around. My Stitch Fix Inspiration Pinterest board, plus requests and information from previous Fixes definitely don’t match up to what I was sent. I’m also bummed because I’m such a huge proponent of Stitch Fix‘s service and how well they typically listen to requests. Overall – huge disappointment.
What do you think? Did you like anything from the fix? Have you ever tried Stitch Fix (aff)? Were you happy with your results?
Love those slim boyfriend jeans, really cute on you! I am not a fan of subscription boxes, I am very picky and am afraid I'd end up sending most of it back :/ I know they work great for some. I think they are more for gals into the minimalistic look. I mostly stick to very unique styles. Thanks for sharing, great post!
Valerie
Fashion And Travel
These clothes are adorable! I'm definitely going to have to check them out 🙂
Aw, bummer nothing worked. I think you made the right decision by sending it all back. Definitely reach out to them about your fix though – their customer service is very responsive and helpful regarding fixes gone bad!
Adorable fit just right on you great for everyday wear.
Bummer. All my friends rave about SF, but I am super scared to try it because I am picky about fit and don't have money to be throwing around. Most of the stuff seems pricey and I'm a bargain hound. Hope you have better luck next round!
This is why I never buy from catalogues – the fit is never right. Sorry that you lucked out.
Wow. That really sucks that you lose out on that stylist fee. It sounds like they didn't really listen to what you wanted at all. Hope it's better next time around.
I ended up canceling my subscription a couple of months ago. I was really optimistic that I would love this service, but it was always pretty meh. Then I saw a vlogger I like unbox her stitch fix and she found the original tag on one of the items (from Nordstrom Rack) that they'd missed/not removed, along with the stitch fix price tag. They had marked up the price they paid over 100%! That decided it for me. It's nice you've typically felt like they listen well. I never got the feeling that my stylist was tuning in very much to what I'd asked for. Best of luck with your next one!
I really liked the boyfriend jeans on you a lot! You have a figure that I feel can truly pull off anything though. I tried out Stitch Fix twice and it was honestly too expensive for me, Ironically, I looked at my last box and was able to find almost the same exact items at Walmart just a few months later (not a crack on Walmart, I thought they were genuinely cute clothes!).
The dress was a nice fit, too bad you didn't like the colors. The pieces looked okay, but if they aren't you, it's a good thing you had the returned. Thanks for the review as well!
Wow so many nice choices. I'm liking what I'm seeing from stitch fix lately. I don't know I could do these type of boxes, but I like you can return! – Jeanine
What cute selections! I like how you can wear them different ways too!
I tried Stitch Fix and never found anything I liked or worth the price. PS Your skinny jeans are cute!
I love the jeans, too! It's great that you can return what you don't like.
Look like your stylist got boho all wrong! The jeans are cute tho 🙂
Love your style! ABSOLUTELY adorable and comfy! I love the return policy, buy with confidence!
I love the jeans and dress!!! The jeans would be so much fun to match with other clothing.
I'm a total online shopper!!! I gues I've just always had great luck with things always fitting!!! Love all of your outfits though 🙂
I have not yet tried the subscription boxes like this but I would love to try this one. I love these outfits you got but if you are not happy with them it is best to send them back. Thanks for sharing.